Jose Carillo's English Forum
English Grammar and Usage Problems => Use and Misuse => Topic started by: Joe Carillo on February 21, 2011, 01:57:56 PM
-
Question sent in by e-mail by Grace N. Toralde (February 20, 2011):
Dear Sir,
I would just like to ask something. Is the question “Are you writing?” correct?
If I ask someone “Are you writing also?”, am I using the correct tense?
My reply to Grace:
The question “Are you writing?” can be taken to mean in at least two ways.
The first is in the context of the speaker asking the person who is unseen or isn’t physically present—perhaps the question is asked over the phone or through a letter or e-mail—if he or she is currently doing some form of professional writing like, say, literature or journalism. The speaker knows that the person being addressed is a writer by profession or avocation and by asking that question, wants confirmation that the person being addressed is, in fact, pursuing that profession or avocation.
The second sense of “Are you writing?” is in the context of the speaker asking the person face to face if he or she is going to write the speaker sometime soon, in the same sense as that of the sentence “Will you write me soon?” or “Will you write me sometime soon?” In this particular case, the speaker is using the interrogative progressive tense form as the semantic equivalent of the interrogative future tense form—a usage that’s perfectly acceptable among native English speakers.
Both of the two senses above of the question “Are you writing?” likewise apply to the question “Are you writing also?” This time, however, the speaker is asking another person the same question he or she had earlier asked someone, and this someone happens to be within hearing distance when the question is asked the second time around. The adverb “also” is added by the speaker to convey the idea that the person he had earlier asked that question answered in the affirmative.
In all the situations described above, the questions “Are you writing?” and “Are you writing also?” are grammatically correct and in the right tense.
-
I think both the questions are grammatically correct. It is depend on you that in which meaning you want to ask this question?
-
I also think that both are right and used in correct tense. Of course, that depends on meaning, which nansyronn mentioned.
-
both
-
so good.
-
I think both the questions are grammatically correct. It is depend on you that in which meaning.. I agree with your thoughts!
______________
crown3ds (http://www.crown3ds-tarjeta.com/)r4 3ds (http://www.r4-3ds.com.br/)
-
Yeah this is really interesting topic,..
-
Very interesting. I think it's grammatically correct.
-
great post, very interesting:)
-
Both the sentences are correct. The meanings will be obviously different.
-
I'm not sure if it is grammatically correct. But I think it's wrong.
------------
garage doors (http://www.upandoverdoorsltd.co.uk/Garage_Doors/)
-
For me both sentences are correct The meanings will be obviously different...
-
I think both the concerns are grammatically appropriate. It is rely on you that in which significance you want to ask this question?
-
Yeah, According to grammar.. Both questions are correct, either it depends on Sentence.... Which one we use.
-
so good.
-
The content written in too are great. Informative and the data is accurate. Very helpful. I am inspired by your hard work and obviously this blog is perfect. Thanks!! I'm wearing my Ugly Christmas shirts (http://www.tshirtpusher.com/Deer-Ugly-Christmas-Sweater-T-Shirt.html) , just saying.