How do we distinguish between noun clauses, adjective clauses, and adverb clauses?
This interesting question about how relative clauses work was raised sometime ago by Forum member Pipes, who posted:
“I would just like to consult you with regard to this sentence: ‘It is believed that computers will make a tremendous impact in today’s education.’
“Am I right that ‘that computers will make a tremendous impact in today’s education’ is a noun clause? And if so, how do you distinguish a noun clause from an adjective clause and from an adverb clause?”
Here’s my reply to Pipes:Yes, in that sentence you presented, the construction “that computers will make a tremendous impact in today’s education” is a
noun clause. It serves as the direct object of the verb “believed,” meaning that it receives the action of that verb.
IMAGE CREDITS: WWW.ENGLISH-GRAMMAR-REVOLUTION.COMRecall that by definition, a
clause is a group of words containing a subject and a predicate that functions as a member of a complex or compound sentence. It works as a relative clause when it is introduced by the relative pronouns “that” or “who” or by the interrogative word “why,” “where,” or “when.” It can then serve in the sentence in any of these three ways: as a noun clause, as an adjective clause, and as an adverb clause.
IMAGE CREDIT: PEDIAA.COMA relative clause functions as noun clause when it serves as the subject or as the direct object of the sentence, as in the following examples:
1. Noun clause as subject of the sentence: “
That the accused will be vindicated in the trial is not a certainty.” (The noun clause is “that the accused will be vindicated in the trial.”)
2. Noun clause as direct object in the sentence: “The woman claims
that she is being harassed by her former employer.” (The noun clause is “that she is being harassed by her former employer.”)
Note that the sentence you presented, “It is believed that computers will make a tremendous impact in today’s education,” follows the same construction pattern as Example #2 above, with the noun clause “that computers will make a tremendous impact in today’s education” serving as direct object of the verb “claims.”
On the other hand, a
relative clause functions as an adjective clause if it serves to modify a noun or pronoun—meaning that it identifies or gives additional information about the subject or the object receiving the action in a sentence. As such,
it works either as a dependent or subordinate clause, linking itself to the main clause by making use of the relative pronouns “that,” which,” “who,” “whom,” or “whose” or of the pronoun “when” or “where.”
The adjective clause can then function in any of these three ways:
1. As an adjective clause modifying the subject in the main clause: “People
who have extensively traveled abroad usually have a broad world view.” (Here, the adjective clause “who have extensively traveled abroad” modifies the subject “people.”)
2. As an adjective clause modifying the object of the verb: “The lawyers couldn’t agree on several terms
that will be used in their legal brief.” (Here, the adjective clause “that will be used in their legal brief” modifies the direct object “terms.”)
3. As an adjective clause serving as object of the preposition: “The letter was delivered to
whom it was addressed.” (Here, the adjective clause “whom it was addressed” is the object of the preposition “to.”)
IMAGE CREDIT: WWW.TALK.EDUFinally, a
relative clause functions as an adverb clause when it modifies the operative verb, an adjective, or another adverb in the sentence, as in the following example:
“The expedition failed to land
where they intended to make the scientific study.” (Here, the adverb clause “where they intended to make the scientific study” modifies the verb “land.”)
This essay, 777th in the series, first appeared in the column “English Plain and Simple” by Jose A. Carillo in the February 4, 2012 issue of The Manila Times
, © 2012 by the Manila Times Publishing Corp. All rights reserved.
